Online Personals Watch
Menu
  • Home
  • About
  • Research
    • News by Company & Categories
    • News by Date
    • All Online Dating Statistics
    • Public Companies
    • Acquisitions
    • Funding Rounds
    • Top Online Dating Reporters
    • OPW in the Press
    • All Executive Interviews
  • Conferences
  • Courtland Brooks
  • Contact
  • Subscribe
Menu

eBay’s Fight Over Counterfeit Jewelry And What It Means For Online Dating

Posted on May 4, 2009

Soudcovske kladivko OPW — May 4 — Tiffany & Co. is in the process of appealing a
judge’s ruling that does not hold eBay responsible for the sale of
counterfeit
merchandise, and if they succeed, it could mean bad news for online
dating. Buyers
take risks everyday when purchasing items listed on eBay. ~6,000 fake
items are for sale on the site at any given time, usually famous luxury
products. In June 2004, Tiffany & Co. decided eBay should take
responsibility for the counterfeit Tiffany
jewelry being sold on the site, and sued. The argument was over whose
job it
was to police the site to help prevent counterfeit merchandise from
being
passed off as authentic. Four years later, on July 14, 2008, the ruling
came down from U.S. District Judge Richard Sullivan: “eBay cannot be
forced to
police its listings to identify counterfeit products. It is the
trademark
owner's burden to police its mark.” Tiffany was devastated by
the ruling, which contradicted several international rulings from the
previous
year. The previous month, a French court awarded LVMH, the parent
company of
Louis Vuitton, nearly $61m in compensation for fraudulent items sold on
eBay.
eBay was also ordered to stop all sales of LVMH perfumes on its French
site. In
2007, Germany’s
highest court said eBay needed to better police online sales to help
stop fake
Rolex watches from being sold. If eBay is going to be responsible to
police
their site for counterfeit products, will online dating websites then become
fully responsible for seeking out and eliminating scammers and spammers?
Both
eBay and online dating sites essentially deal with the publication of
classified ads, and making the service provider responsible for policing one
type of classified could easily be translated into the responsibility of all
providers of that type. A lawsuit was recently filed against eHarmony.com
claiming that the site does not actually have a scientific matching system in place,
and one woman was matched with a scam artist. If a ruling is made in favor of
Tiffany & Co., could dating sites then be sued for the simple fact that a scam
artist was in their system to be matched with women looking for love? Only time
will tell, but none of the implications are positive for the online dating
industry.

See all posts on eHarmony

Share this:

  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn
  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email

Related


← Previous Post
Next Post →

2 thoughts on “eBay’s Fight Over Counterfeit Jewelry And What It Means For Online Dating”

  1. Unknown's avatar Ross Williams says:
    May 4, 2009 at 3:04 pm

    Mark, you’ve missed your normal disclosure here – Iovation, the anti-scam technology is your customer 🙂
    I think online dating is a fair way from being hit with this kind of legislation – fundamentlaly, eBay makes money from selling scam merchandise. However, most dating companies know that scammers reduce retention and increase churn – so on a purely financial basis it makes no sense to harbour scammers.
    That said, it is a difficult thing to police – technology is part of it, but people and culture within the dating company are also important. We’ve started targeting our customer service teams and bonusing them on the number of scammers removed, helping them to be as pro-active as possible and make life as hard as possible for scammers.
    This piece above should be taken with a pinch of salt – it’s certainly worth following but I would put a bunch of other larger industries above online dating for any legislation.

    Reply
  2. Unknown's avatar Ross Williams says:
    May 4, 2009 at 3:04 pm

    Mark, you’ve missed your normal disclosure here – Iovation, the anti-scam technology is your customer 🙂
    I think online dating is a fair way from being hit with this kind of legislation – fundamentlaly, eBay makes money from selling scam merchandise. However, most dating companies know that scammers reduce retention and increase churn – so on a purely financial basis it makes no sense to harbour scammers.
    That said, it is a difficult thing to police – technology is part of it, but people and culture within the dating company are also important. We’ve started targeting our customer service teams and bonusing them on the number of scammers removed, helping them to be as pro-active as possible and make life as hard as possible for scammers.
    This piece above should be taken with a pinch of salt – it’s certainly worth following but I would put a bunch of other larger industries above online dating for any legislation.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

  • YouTube
  • X
  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook
Graphic featuring the logo of Courtland Brooks with the text 'We'll Help You Grow, Thrive & Exit' and bullet points for services including Strategy, Marketing, PR, Influencers, and Business Development.

OUR EVENTS

A blurred audience in a large venue with colorful lighting, featuring the bold text 'LTR US' in the foreground.

OUR SPONSORS

Logo of HubPeople featuring geometric shapes and the text 'HubPeople' in a modern font.
Logo of InnerVue featuring stylized graphic elements and the brand name in elegant typography.
Logo of LeadThink, featuring the tagline 'YOUR GROWTH STARTS WITH US' and the description 'The #1 Destination for Early to Late-Stage Startups' in a combination of blue and pink text.

GOT NEWS?

Share your news at
tips@onlinepersonalswatch.com.

COURTLAND BROOKS

We help online dating & social businesses grow, thrive, and exit. See CourtlandBrooks.com.

CONTACT

Mark Brooks
CEO, Courtland Brooks
Publisher, Online Personals Watch
mark@courtlandbrooks.com

Irena Brooks
Editor, Online Personals Watch
irena@courtlandbrooks.com

©2026 Online Personals Watch